top of page
  • Youtube
Secure Upload MM Insurance
Make A Payment MM Insurance
  • Instagram

Meet Our Insurance Team - New Berlin, WI and Across the Midwest

Independent Since 1997, Serving Clients in 24 States

Independent means we don't work for one carrier, we work for you. We shop dozens of companies to find the right mix of coverage and cost, and when your situation changes, we re-shop it instead of defending one company's product. Our office is in New Berlin, and we're serving clients in 24 states whose homes, businesses, and investment properties cross state lines.

How We Work With New Clients

First, we get to know you, whether that's over coffee or a cocktail. Then we get to know your business and your goals, so we're assessing the risks that are actually specific to you instead of handing you a template. From there we shop the market and bring you real options, with a plain explanation of what each one does and doesn't cover. You end up knowing exactly what you bought, and you have peace of mind knowing you're protected.

50 Years in Southeastern Wisconsin

MM Insurance Associates has been placing coverage for southeastern Wisconsin families and businesses for more than 50 years, and has operated as a fully independent agency since 1997. Ownership has changed hands; the standard hasn't. Get it right the first time, and be reachable when something actually goes wrong.

Meet the Team

You'll work with the same small team every time you call. No call center, no ticket number.

Toby Hartman MM Insurance

Toby Hartman

Owner / Sales

Toby loves spending time with his wife and 2 kids. When not with family, Toby is waterskiing, downhill skiing, or struggling to break 90 on the course.

  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
Molly Hartman MM Insurance

Molly Hartman

Customer Service Representative

It's rare to see Molly without her sidekick Daisy, a beautiful Golden Retriever. When not walking Daisy, Molly is volunteering or at the lake with family.   

Emily Wisdorf MM Insurance

Emily Wisdorf

Executive Assistant

As a new mom, Emily enjoys spending most of her time with her family. When not chasing her daughters around, Emily can be found working on her custom sugar cookie business.

Scott Johanek MM Insurance

Scott Johanek

Growth & Digital Strategist

When Scott or his wife Michelle aren't flipping a house (or recently a bank) you can usually find him on a golf course or searching for Wisconsin's best Old Fashioned.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
Amy Rambow MM Insurance

Amy Rambow

Senior Account Manager

Amy can often be found exploring state and national parks or at the roller-skating rink practicing her moves. She loves to spend time with her husband, 3 kids and her new daughter-in-law. 

Teresa Kaasa MM Insurance

Teresa Kaasa

Operations & Commercial Lines

Happily married with two daughters and three grandkids, she loves traveling, sports, family time and mentoring women as a Mary Kay team leader.

LJ MM Insurance

Lady Joy (LJ)

Executive Assistant

LJ loves the beach and the outdoors. If not outside LJ spends time with her 2 dogs at home binge watching Netflix or managing her small clothing line.

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page
\n