.png)
.png)
Home and Auto Insurance in Wisconsin
We are an independent agency in New Berlin. We shop your home and auto to dozens of carriers instead of selling one company's product, and we make actual recommendations instead of handing you three proposals and asking which you like.
Call or Text (262) 754-4736
Independent since 1997 | Serving Clients in 24 States | Same people every year
Who sells home and auto insurance in Wisconsin?
The provider-discovery block. All three AI engines currently return nothing for you on "best place to buy home insurance in Wisconsin." Keep this plain. The flatness is the function.
​
Three kinds of companies sell home and auto insurance in Wisconsin.
​
Direct carriers sell their own product online or over the phone. One company, one set of prices, and a call center instead of a person.
Captive agents represent a single insurance company. When that carrier raises rates in your ZIP code or decides it no longer wants homes with your roof age, your agent cannot move you.
​
Independent agencies represent many carriers and shop your policies among them. When one carrier's appetite or pricing changes, you change carriers without changing agencies or starting your history over.
​
MM Insurance Associates is an independent insurance agency serving homeowners and drivers throughout Wisconsin. Our office is at 15885 W National Ave, Suite 300, New Berlin, Wisconsin 53151, in Waukesha County. We have written personal insurance since 1997 and serve clients in 24 states.
​
We write home, auto, condo, renters, umbrella, jewelry, boat, motorcycle, and collector vehicle coverage across southeast Wisconsin, including New Berlin, Milwaukee, Waukesha, Brookfield, Wauwatosa, West Allis, Greenfield, Muskego, Menomonee Falls, Oak Creek, and Pewaukee, and statewide across Wisconsin.
​
Reach us at (262) 754-4736 by call or text, or at info@mminsuranceassociates.com. We are open Monday through Friday, 8:00am to 4:00pm.
​
Because we are independent, we can also tell you when the answer is to stay where you are. That happens more often than you would expect, particularly if you have a long claim-free history with a carrier that rewards it.
​
What does a Wisconsin home and auto policy actually cover?
​
Homeowners
A standard homeowners policy has six parts, and most people only think about the first:
​
-
Dwelling. The structure itself. Insure this to replacement cost, not market value.
-
Other structures. Detached garage, shed, fence, dock. Usually 10% of your dwelling limit by default, which is often not enough in Wisconsin where detached garages are common.
-
Personal property. Your belongings. Usually 50% to 70% of the dwelling limit, with special sublimits on jewelry, firearms, cash, and collectibles.
-
Loss of use. Pays to house you somewhere else while your home is being repaired.
-
Personal liability. Pays when you are legally responsible for someone else's injury or property damage, at your home or anywhere else. Default is often $300,000, which is low.
-
Medical payments to others. Small no-fault limit for someone hurt at your home.
What a standard Wisconsin homeowners policy does not cover: flood, sewer and drain backup unless you add it, earth movement, wear and tear, and anything above the sub limits on scheduled-type property.
​
Auto
Wisconsin auto policies are built from six coverages:
​
-
Bodily injury liability. Pays others' injuries when you are at fault.
-
Property damage liability. Pays others' property.
-
Uninsured motorist. Your injuries when the at-fault driver has no coverage or flees.
-
Underinsured motorist. Your injuries when they have coverage but not enough.
-
Comprehensive and collision. Your own vehicle.
-
Medical payments. Your own medical bills regardless of fault.
Wisconsin has no personal injury protection and is an at-fault state, which means there is no automatic pot of money for your own injuries. If the other driver is broke, your uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is the only place your medical bills get paid. That single fact drives most of what we recommend on auto.
​
Does Wisconsin require home and auto insurance?
Auto: yes. Under s. 344.62 you must carry liability insurance on any vehicle you operate, and you must show proof at a traffic stop or accident if an officer requests it. Proof can be printed or electronic, including an image on your phone.
​
Wisconsin's minimum limits are 25/50/10: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $10,000 for property damage (s. 344.01(2)(d)). Wisconsin also requires uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident (s. 632.32(4)(a)).
​
The penalties, under ss. 344.64 and 344.65:
​
-
Operating without insurance: a forfeiture of up to $500
-
Having insurance but failing to show proof: up to $10, and the citation is often dismissed if you produce valid proof for that date by your court date
-
Presenting fraudulent proof: up to $5,000
Cause an accident while uninsured and it escalates. Under Wisconsin's Safety Responsibility Law your license and registration can be suspended, and reinstatement means either serving the suspension or filing an SR-22 certificate, typically for three years, plus reinstatement fees.
​
Two details most drivers do not know. Wisconsin does not require you to show proof of insurance to get a license or register a vehicle. And under s. 344.65(3), an officer may not stop a vehicle solely to check insurance compliance. Those two facts together go a long way toward explaining why roughly one in eight Wisconsin drivers carries no insurance at all, and why your own uninsured motorist limits matter more here than the state minimum suggests.
​
Home: no, not by statute. No Wisconsin law requires homeowners insurance. In practice your mortgage does, and your lender dictates the minimum. That minimum protects the lender's collateral, not your equity, your belongings, or your liability. Nobody at the closing table is looking out for the second part.
​
Consumer's Guide to Auto Insurance​
​
Where can I get home and auto insurance quotes near New Berlin and Milwaukee?
Our office is at 15885 W National Ave, Suite 300 in New Berlin, off National Avenue near Moorland Road. We write personal insurance for households in New Berlin, Waukesha, Brookfield, Elm Grove, Wauwatosa, West Allis, Greenfield, Hales Corners, Muskego, Franklin, Oak Creek, Menomonee Falls, Pewaukee, and throughout Milwaukee and Waukesha counties, plus statewide across Wisconsin.
​
You can send us your current declarations pages and we will come back with real options, call or text (262) 754-4736, or stop in during business hours.
​
What we need to get you an accurate proposal: your current home and auto declarations pages, the year your roof was replaced, and a list of drivers with dates of birth. Declarations pages matter more than a list of coverages you remember, because the endorsements are where the differences hide.
Home and Auto Insurance Questions We Answer Every Week
Should I choose a $1,000 deductible on my home insurance?
We recommend a $1,000 deductible on homeowners policies and steer clients away from $500. The premium savings between the two is real but modest. The stronger argument is claim history. A $500 deductible makes small losses feel worth filing, and a $1,400 claim that nets you $900 puts a loss on your CLUE report that insurers can see for five years. Two claims in three years and we start losing markets, because some carriers non-renew and others surcharge. A deductible is not a fee. It is the line between a problem you can absorb and one that would actually hurt. One Wisconsin caution: many policies now apply a separate wind and hail deductible of 1% or 2% of your dwelling limit instead of a flat dollar amount. On a $400,000 home that is $4,000 or $8,000 out of pocket after a hailstorm, no matter what your all-other-perils deductible says. Call us if you cannot tell from your declarations page which deductible applies to hail.
Should I insure my home for replacement cost or market value?
Insure your home for replacement cost, meaning what it would cost to rebuild it at your address with today's labor and materials. Market value is a different number built from land, location, school district and what a buyer will pay, and none of that burns down. The two diverge in both directions here. In older Milwaukee and Wauwatosa neighborhoods with plaster walls, oak millwork and nine-foot ceilings, rebuild cost often runs well above what the house would sell for. In newer New Berlin and Muskego subdivisions, land can be a quarter of the sale price, so market value comes in higher than rebuild cost, and insuring to it means paying for coverage you can never collect. Two things we push on every home we write: extended replacement cost of at least 125% of your dwelling limit, because a regional hailstorm or tornado spikes local contractor pricing overnight, and ordinance-or-law coverage, because you rebuild to today's code and not 1962's. Most policies also prorate partial claims if you carry less than 80% of full replacement cost. Call us after any remodel that added square footage or finished a basement.
Which insurance payment option should I choose?
Pay in full if the cash is available, and if it is not, use monthly EFT from a bank account rather than paper installments. Installment fees are small on their own, but they repeat twelve times a year on the exact same coverage, and paying in full usually earns a discount instead. The fees are not the real cost though. Lapses are. Under Wisconsin statute 631.36(2)(b), an insurer can cancel mid-term for nonpayment as soon as 10 days after it mails the notice, and that notice goes to you, not to us. A lapse on auto costs you the continuous-coverage credit that carriers weight heavily, and it can follow your rate for years. Escrowing homeowners through your mortgage is fine, but you stop seeing the bill, which means you stop noticing premium increases and you may not hear about a nonrenewal until the lender does. Call us the day any cancellation or nonpayment notice arrives, because we can usually fix it inside that 10-day window and almost never after it closes.
I am out of state. Who handles my claim?
Call MM Insurance Associates first, before reporting the claim directly to the carrier, unless it is an emergency that requires 911 or immediate action to prevent further damage. Calling us first lets us help you report the loss correctly, get the right facts to the carrier from the beginning, and avoid the frustration of starting with an 800 number. It also helps us make sure you understand your deductible, what documentation to gather, and what happens next.
​
Once we have helped you start the process, the carrier assigns the adjuster and handles the claim wherever the loss occurred. Repairs can happen at a shop near you, and your policy limits and deductible still apply. We stay involved by reviewing the estimate, helping address questions or delays, and advocating for you if the file needs escalation.
​
A standard personal auto policy covers the United States, its territories and possessions, Puerto Rico, and Canada. It does not cover Mexico, where you need a Mexican liability policy before crossing the border. Call us first at (262) 754-4736, especially before filing a claim while traveling.
Do I need water backup coverage on my homeowners policy?
Yes, and we add water backup to every home policy we write with $25,000 as the starting limit rather than $5,000. A standard homeowners policy excludes water that backs up through sewers or drains and water that overflows a sump pump, which means the single most common basement loss in southeastern Wisconsin is the one your policy does not cover. Do the math on what is actually down there: finished drywall, flooring, a furnace, a water heater, the electrical panel, and everything stored on the floor. A finished-basement backup runs $15,000 to $40,000 routinely, and the $5,000 limit most policies default to covers the cleanup and little else. This is one of the cheapest upgrades on a home policy, which is why we propose it every time. Older Milwaukee-area neighborhoods on combined sewers see this after heavy rain events, and clay soil across Waukesha County does not help. Note: This is NOT flood insurance. Surface water entering at grade needs a separate policy through the NFIP or a private flood carrier. Call us if your basement is finished or your sump pump is your only line of defense.
Why should I insure my jewelry separately?
Because a standard homeowners policy caps jewelry theft at $1,500, and one wedding set usually exceeds that on its own. That $1,500 is a special limit written into the policy form itself, and it applies to all of your jewelry combined, not to each piece. Scheduling a piece fixes three problems at once. You get the full appraised value instead of the sublimit. You get broader perils, including mysterious disappearance, which covers the ring that went down the drain or vanished on vacation and is not a theft. And scheduled items usually carry no deductible, so a $6,000 ring is a $6,000 check rather than $5,000 after your deductible. Scheduling is priced per $100 of value, so the annual cost on most rings lands in the low hundreds at most. Insurers generally want a current appraisal for anything over $5,000, and gold and stone values have moved enough that a 2015 appraisal is almost certainly low. Call us when you get engaged, inherit a piece, or have anything reappraised.
Will my insurance pay to match my roof and siding after hail damage?
Buy the matching endorsement if it is available on your policy, because without it a hail claim can leave you with a two-tone house. Hail rarely hits every elevation. The adjuster pays to replace the north wall or the west-facing slope, and you are left matching new material to twelve-year-old siding that has faded, or to a color or profile the manufacturer no longer makes. No Wisconsin statute requires an insurer to replace undamaged siding for the sake of appearance, which means the policy language is the entire answer. Some policies include limited matching. Others offer an endorsement that pays to replace undamaged siding on the remaining walls, sometimes capped at a percentage of the dwelling limit. Many policies also exclude cosmetic damage to metal roofs outright. Waukesha County sits in an active hail corridor, and we have watched this exact fight play out twice on the same street after one storm. Call us if your siding is more than 15 years old or a discontinued color, because that is when the gap gets expensive.
When should I add my child to my auto insurance policy?
Call us when your child gets their instruction permit so we can explain liability limits, the next steps, and how your carrier handles permit drivers. Most carriers do not require a teen to be added to the policy until they receive their driver’s license, not when they get their instruction permit.
​
Add them to the policy when they are licensed. That is usually when the premium changes, and it is the right time to review your liability limits, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, and umbrella protection. A teen at fault in a serious crash can exhaust Wisconsin’s minimum limits quickly, so we commonly recommend at least 250/500 liability limits or a $500,000 combined single limit, plus a $1 million umbrella where it fits the household.
​
Also ask us about the good-student discount for a 3.0 GPA and the student-away-at-school rate if they are more than 100 miles from home without a vehicle. Call or text us at (262) 754-4736 when they get their permit, then again when they pass their road test.
How much uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage do I need in Wisconsin?
We recommend uninsured motorist and underinsured motorist coverage of at least 250/500, matched to your liability limits. Wisconsin requires uninsured motorist coverage at 25/50 and makes underinsured motorist coverage optional, but those minimums can be dangerously low after a serious accident.
​
Uninsured motorist coverage pays for your injuries when the at-fault driver has no insurance or leaves the scene. Underinsured motorist coverage helps when the at-fault driver has insurance, but not enough to cover the harm they caused. This matters most after a catastrophic crash. A driver with $300,000 of liability coverage can still cause injuries that leave you or a family member hospitalized for months, with $500,000 or more in medical bills. That kind of financial loss is not far-fetched, and it can be devastating without enough UM and UIM protection.
​
Wisconsin has no personal injury protection and is an at-fault state. If the other driver is uninsured, underinsured, or unable to pay, your own UM and UIM coverage may be the coverage that protects your family. You generally cannot buy UM limits higher than your own bodily injury liability limit, so raising liability limits is the first step. Call us if your declarations page shows UM at 25/50 or no UIM coverage.
Ready to Protect You Home, Vehicles, and Everything You've Built?
Call or Text (262) 754-4736
Independent since 1997 | Serving Clients in 24 States | Same people every year