.png)
.png)
MM Insurance Associates Reviews
Read Google reviews of MM Insurance Associates in New Berlin, Wisconsin. Browse feedback about business insurance, home and auto, property insurance, life insurance, and the service people receive from our team.
Rated 5.0 on Google from 90+ reviews.
Everything is as displayed on September 7, 2026.
Call or Text (262) 754-4736
Below are excerpts from written Google reviews, grouped by topic, followed by ratings submitted without written comments. Each account reflects the reviewer's experience at the time it was posted.
Read the reviews on Google
29
Years
Independent agency since 1997
5.0 on Google
Top rated agency with 90+ Reviews
12.5 Minutes
Average certificate turnaround time
24
States
Clients served beyond Wisconsin
30+ Carriers
Available to shop during renewals
Business Insurance Reviews
Read feedback about business insurance, coverage guidance, and working with our commercial insurance team.
Greg Kusnierz
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a month ago
“Toby and his team have been responsive, knowledgeable, and attentive, offering tailored recommendations that align with both our operational needs and budget.”
M Miller
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Eighteen years- Associates Engineering Systems. We are extremely happy with this Family business. M&M Insurance is there when needed!”
Jordan Mudrock
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 years ago
“Quick and efficient at a great rate!”
Jessica Henthorn
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Thanks to Toby and Molly, managing the insurance aspect of multiple businesses is efficient and effortless.”
Nancy Lange
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Toby, Mary, and Molly are wonderful to work with. Their response time is quick and they are able to address all our business needs.”
brad weber
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“MM Insurance is the provider for my company and Molly in customer service is always helpful and super responsive with any requests we may have”
Built With Brick llc
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“I feel valued as a customer with MM. The whole team is helpful, responsive, educational, and honest.”
Elle Johnson
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Written perfectly to C5 Expediting specifications and affordable.”
Paul De Luca
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Our multifaceted construction company has utilized MM Insurance for over 20 years.”
Larry K
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Toby and his team have provided me with the best experience ever for our insurance needs.”
Home & Auto Insurance Reviews
Read feedback about home and auto insurance, including policy changes, new home construction, and help during claims.
Don Balke
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 days ago
“It is refreshing to get caring messages instead of sales pitches. Great staff!”
Gina Arenz
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“MM Insurance shopped around and saved me a bundle on home/auto!”
Kate Stelter
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Brandi was able to save us almost a third on our household insurance needs! The process was pleasantly quick and painless.”
Jill Brunic
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | Edited 2 years ago
“Toby, Cole, and Molly all played a part in making every aspect of this process smooth and easy for me.”
Nancy Robie
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“From the get-go MM Insurance helped us with our new home construction insurance options.”
Dr FelterSnatch
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“He was very generous with his time, extremely patient and incredibly knowledgeable.”
Cathy Leszczynski
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Toby has been amazing to our family. We had chimney and roof damage. Toby handled all the claims for us. Fantastic service! Thank you”
Marsha Coats
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Toby's persistence succeeded in getting my expenses, after being rear-ended, covered. We couldn't be happier with the courtesy and follow up of MM Insurance Associates.”
Amie Kusch
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“John was great to work with and made the process of setting up my new car insurance very easy!”
Anthony Alonzo
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“MM ins.was very proficient and on top of things from start to finish with our auto and home policies.Would highly recommend.”
Connie Rist
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Switched all my car, home, and umbrella coverage to Carter and he’s been great. He saved me money and I got better coverage.”
Real Estate & Property Insurance Reviews
Read feedback about investment property coverage and other property insurance needs.
Alexander Hoffmann
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 11 months ago
“They helped me get a policy for an investment property. Easy to work with and communicative throughout the whole process.”
Lou Elson
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“MM Insurance got the new policy active and saved the closings on 2 properties within 1 week.”
Dick Fisher
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“We have a difficult-to-insure property, and Toby has gone to bat for us, over and over, to get the job done!”
Life Insurance Reviews
Read feedback about life insurance options and the application process.
Val Sanchez
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 7 months ago
“I bought an affordable life insurance policy through them. The process was simple and any concern/issue I had was resolved.”
Luke LaCrosse
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Their communication was consistent throughout the process, and enrollment in my new policy was both seamless and efficient.”
Andy Howard
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Getting life insurance sounds like a drag but Toby really made the process as easy as possible”
M O
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Toby made it easy for my wife and myself to get life insurance.”
Specialty Vehicle Insurance Reviews
Read feedback about insurance for specialty vehicles.
Jacob Scoby
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“She texted me in less than 5 minutes a copy of my card even at the dog park!”
Business & Personal Insurance Reviews
Read feedback that mentions both business and personal insurance.
Sara Swosinski
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“I highly recommend them for any personal and business needs when considering insurance services!”
Andy Haros
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 years ago
“I have been using all their services in both commercial and residential needs.”
Kristen Belan
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“We use MM for all of our auto, home, and business insurance. We highly recommend MM and refer them to our family and friends.”
Michelle Johanek
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“MM Insurance helped me organize everything I needed for my new business, and saved me money on my personal insurance.”
Zeke Miller
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Truly a professional company. They care about the people they work with like family.”
General Service & Insurance Guidance Reviews
Read feedback about communication, insurance guidance, and working with the MM Insurance Associates team.
Amy Pfaffman
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 days ago
“This team goes above and beyond and gets it done with a smile. I'm grateful to get to work with them.”
J Rob
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 6 months ago
“Questions are answered clearly. Coverage is explained thoroughly. And when you need something, they respond — quickly and professionally.”
Joe
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 9 months ago
“My request for a comparison quote on insurance coverage was met with professional an very prompt response. I appreciate this type of quality service.”
Scott Hansen
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 10 months ago
“In the end, Toby got us better coverage at a much lower rate than what we had with a large WI based insurance company.”
Chris Costello
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 10 months ago
“new annual review is top notch service. thanks”
Peter Chapman
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Brandi is a great account manager, highly recommend!”
Lisa Snider
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Toby has done a great job helping us with complex insurance issues, he constantly goes above and beyond to help us.”
Chris Seeley
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“She got the questions answered that I needed, asked if I preferred being called or emailed, and did everything in a timely manor.”
Erin & Robert Von Rueden
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Brandi was very helpful through the entire process and even sent me a comparison from my current coverage to their proposal.”
Beverly Dethardt
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Service was outstanding. Brandy was very good at putting my concerns at ease.Her concern for my situation was admirable.She knows her stuff.Thanks again”
Susan Miglautsch
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Working with MMI insurance has been great. Molly has been very helpful!”
Amie Droese
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Great service that is attentive, responsive and thoughtful. I highly recommend MM Insurance.”
Todd Wollenberg
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“I just switched to MM and am happy so far. Brandi was very helpful.”
Luc Leszczynski
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Working with John and MM has been great!”
Dan Kritter
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | a year ago
“Organized and pleasant team. Efficient. Nice to work with.”
Michael Colander
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | Edited 2 years ago
“Everyone is so kind and works hard to give us the best rates. Highly recommend.”
Linda Shimon
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | Edited 2 years ago
“Toby and his sister Molly are always so good at getting back to people and taking care of all the details.”
Elliot Fehlen
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 years ago
“Toby treated us with kindness and respect. He walked us through multiple options and we settled on something that worked well for our family.”
Chris Cagle
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 years ago
“Always professional and responsive whenever I need them. Honest and trustworthy people!”
Allen Hawkins
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 2 years ago
“Easy process and quick turnaround.”
Charles Hurd
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | Edited 2 years ago
“Excellent service and attention to detail.”
John Williams
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“The folks at MM Insurance have taken exceptional care of me both personally and professionally. They go above and beyond in every situation.”
James Quertermous
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“MM Insurance has always delivered exceptional customer service in a timely fashion.”
Ben Colianni
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Molly is also very proactive about contacting me when premiums or audits are due.”
Nathan Kowalczyk
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“John Misiewicz and his team are fantastic. When my wife and I needed help, everything was taken care of.”
Kendra Hurst
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“At MM Insurance, I feel confident to call Molly with any of my questions.”
Mary Ann
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Any time I have any questions about the policies or billing and contact Molly she is very quick to respond.”
Andrei Mikhail
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Profesional and personable. They have the infrastructure and resolve to service all the different dimensions of coverage.”
Ben Tutewohl
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Had a great experience with MM Insurance. Very professional, timely, and helpful. Would recommend to anyone.”
Matt Shimon
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Toby and his team are awesome, super friendly and always willing to assist with anything we need. Highly recommended.”
Christy Owen
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Very responsive to questions and quick to solve problems. MM Insurance makes my life easier!”
AMY BATES
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Great experience working with Mary and the whole office team. Highly recommend”
Tim Quirk
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Wonderful people to work with. I've been doing business with them for over 20 years.”
Sprinter Cargo
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Great service the best prices the mm team knows what they are doing”
Sean Schoenecker
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Always available for questions. They show they really care about people.”
Safeway Medical LLC
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Excellent coustmer service, would highly recommend”
Mike K
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Excellent customer service and attention to detail!”
Larry T
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 3 years ago
“Had the best Experience 👌 A-1!!! …”
Robin Weber
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“My agent John, as well as the entire office is knowledgeable, professional and very attentive to my specific needs.”
Christopher Peterson
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Toby and his staff did an outstanding job. They responded promptly to my call. l would recommend them to anyone. Thanks!”
Heather Gille
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 4 years ago
“Carter was wonderful to work with. He was very direct and prompt with any questions I had. Will recommend him to anyone.”
John Terrence
★★★★★ | 5 stars | Google review | 5 years ago
“Toby and his team have been great to work with.”
Additional Google Ratings
These reviewers submitted a five-star rating without a written comment.
Discovery Outdoor Services
5 stars | 2 months ago
Les O'Hara
5 stars | 4 months ago
Sue Wirkus
5 stars | 2 years ago
Beverly Dethardt
5 stars | 2 years ago
Kevin
5 stars | 3 years ago
Mary Suminski
5 stars | 3 years ago
Bill Kadrich
5 stars | 3 years ago
Emma Sinnott
5 stars | 3 years ago
Pat Larrabee
5 stars | 3 years ago
T.J. Deiter
5 stars | 3 years ago
TANGIE WILLIAMS
5 stars | 3 years ago
Assured Recovery
5 stars | 3 years ago
Soshanna Lee
5 stars | 3 years ago
Jacob Brown
5 stars | 4 years ago
Robin Hartman
5 stars | 4 years ago
Carter Pritchard
5 stars | 4 years ago
Karli Pritchard
5 stars | 4 years ago