The Safety Features That Actually Matter When You Put a New Driver Behind the Wheel
- Toby Hartman

- Jun 26
- 7 min read
By Toby Hartman, MM Insurance Associates
This one is personal for me. I have a 16 year old driver in my house right now, and I also have nieces and nephews who all just got their licenses around the same time. So I am living this decision as a parent and an uncle, not just as an insurance guy.
Here is the honest truth. After two decades in the insurance world, I am not losing sleep over the little fender benders. Those happen, they get fixed, and everybody moves on. What keeps me up is the serious stuff, the kind of crash where the safety features built into the vehicle are the difference between a scary story and a tragedy. When you are choosing a vehicle for a new driver, that is the lens I want you to use.
Why this matters so much for 16 and 17 year olds
New drivers are the most at risk group on the road, and the numbers are not close. According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, the fatal crash rate per mile driven for 16 to 17 year olds is about three times the rate for drivers 20 and older. Based on all police reported crashes, drivers ages 16 to 19 crash at nearly four times the rate of adult drivers per mile driven. Risk is highest at age 16. In fact, 16 year olds crash at roughly one and a half times the rate of 18 and 19 year olds per mile driven.
Night driving makes it worse. For teen drivers, the fatal crash rate at night is about three times as high as it is during the day. Combine inexperience, the tendency to get distracted, and a vehicle without modern safety technology, and you have a recipe I do not want any family to test.
That is the case for spending a little more on the right features. Not every feature, and not the most expensive trim on the lot. The features that have actually been proven to prevent the crashes that hurt people.
1. Lane assist that keeps a distracted driver in their lane
This is the one I push hardest, and the research backs it up. New drivers drift, especially when they glance away for a second. IIHS research found that lane departure warning lowers the rate of single vehicle, sideswipe, and head on crashes by about 11 percent, and the injury versions of those same crashes by about 21 percent. A separate federal study estimated that lane keeping assist makes a vehicle about 24 percent less likely to be involved in a fatal road departure crash. Those head on and run off the road crashes are exactly the catastrophic events I worry about. If I had to pick one feature, this is it.
2. Automatic emergency braking and front crash prevention
If lane assist is my number one, this is right beside it. Forward collision warning paired with automatic emergency braking cuts rear end crashes roughly in half, and cuts the rear end crashes that cause injuries by more than half. New drivers follow too closely and react too slowly. A vehicle that can hit the brakes when your teen does not buys back the experience they have not earned yet. Many vehicles bundle this with lane assist, so look for both together.
3. Backup cameras and rear cross traffic alert
Backup cameras are standard on basically every vehicle built in the last several years, and that is a good thing. Most teen backing incidents are low speed parking lot dents, but the serious risk is the small child or cyclist a new driver simply does not see. A backup camera, and even better a rear cross traffic alert, removes a blind spot that experience would normally cover.
4. Phone integration to stop distracted driving
This is where Apple CarPlay and Android Auto earn their keep. Distraction is one of the biggest threats to young drivers, and teens are among the most likely to be reaching for a phone. A phone that is talking to you, reading your texts, and handling your directions hands free is a phone that is not in your teen's hand. CarPlay is not a luxury feature in my book. It is a distraction prevention tool. Pair it with a family rule that the phone stays in the glove box, and you have addressed the threat from two directions.
5. Reliability, which usually means a newer vehicle
A safety feature you cannot count on is not a safety feature. Newer vehicles tend to be more reliable, and they also carry the safety technology above as standard equipment, which older vehicles often lack entirely. There is a real tradeoff here with budget, and I get it. My rule of thumb is simple. If your child is driving locally in your own community at low speeds, you can get by with a dependable grandma's car. But if you expect your teen on the freeway, or driving more than 10 to 15 miles to school or work, that is when I would invest in a newer vehicle with the modern features.
6. All wheel drive or four wheel drive, depending on your climate
Here in Wisconsin this is not optional thinking. We deal with snow, ice, and wet roads for a big chunk of the year, and a new driver has not built the instincts to handle a vehicle that loses traction. All wheel drive will not stop you faster on ice, so it is not a license to drive carelessly, but it does help a new driver keep control in the conditions we actually drive in. If you are in a warm, dry climate, you can weigh this differently. If you are anywhere with real winters, I would put it high on the list.
My top 5 vehicle recommendations for a new driver
These picks lean on the IIHS and Consumer Reports recommended vehicles for teens, and I weighted them toward the features above, strong crash test ratings, standard automatic emergency braking, phone integration, and for our climate, available all wheel drive. Bigger and heavier generally protects better than small and light, so do not put your new driver in the tiniest car on the lot if you can help it.
Subaru Outback or Forester. A safety standout for our winters. All wheel drive is standard, the EyeSight system bundles automatic emergency braking and lane keeping, and reliability is excellent. My personal top pick for a Wisconsin teen.
Honda CR-V. A roomy, reliable small SUV with Honda Sensing, which pairs automatic emergency braking with lane keeping, plus available all wheel drive and CarPlay. A great all around choice.
Toyota Camry. A consistent IIHS teen list favorite. Toyota Safety Sense is standard, it is famously reliable, and the midsize size adds crash protection. CarPlay included.
Hyundai Tucson. Frequently on the more affordable end of the IIHS teen list, with standard automatic emergency braking, lane keeping, CarPlay, and available all wheel drive.
Mazda 3. If you want a car rather than an SUV, this is a strong pick with standard driver assistance features, good crash ratings, and an easy to drive feel. Best for milder climates or as a second option.
Whatever you choose, the priority order stays the same. Look for standard automatic emergency braking and lane assist first, confirm the phone integration, add all wheel drive if you deal with winter, and lean newer for reliability.
A quick word on insurance
Adding a teen driver to your policy is going to raise your premium. That is just reality, because the data we talked about is the same data the carriers use. The good news is that the safer vehicle choice often helps on two fronts. Many of these safety features can qualify for discounts, and fewer claims over time protect your rate. More importantly, the right vehicle protects the person, and that is the part no premium can replace.
Our tendency in America is to save money, and most of the time that instinct serves us well. But there are a few things that are not worth skimping on in the recipe, and the vehicle that carries your new driver is one of them.
Frequently asked questions
Is an older, cheaper car a bad idea for a new driver?
Not necessarily. For short, low speed local driving, a dependable older vehicle can be fine. The concern is that older vehicles usually lack automatic emergency braking and lane assist, the two features most proven to prevent serious crashes. If your teen will drive on highways or longer distances, lean toward a newer vehicle.
Which single safety feature matters most?
If I had to pick one, lane assist, because run off the road and head on crashes are among the most catastrophic for new drivers and the research shows real reductions. Automatic emergency braking is a very close second.
Should I get all wheel drive for my teen?
In Wisconsin and similar winter climates, I would weight it heavily. It helps a new driver maintain control in snow and on wet roads. In warm, dry climates it matters far less.
Does a safer vehicle lower my insurance cost?
It can help. Certain safety features may qualify for discounts, and a vehicle that helps your teen avoid claims protects your rate over time. We are always happy to walk through how a specific vehicle affects your policy before you buy.
Can MM Insurance help me think this through before I buy?
Absolutely. That is exactly the kind of conversation we like to have. Call us before you sign the paperwork and we will help you weigh the vehicle, the coverage, and the cost together.
Let's keep your new driver safe
If you have a new driver in your household, or one on the way, I would genuinely love to help you think it through. Call our team at (262) 754-4736 or visit mminsuranceassociates.com. We will make sure both the vehicle and the coverage are built to protect the people who matter most to you.



Comments